The Best Tyreek Hill Rookie Cards to Invest In

Tyreek Hill, the electrifying wide receiver for the Miami Dolphins, has emerged as one of the most dynamic and thrilling players in the NFL.

Known for his blazing speed and remarkable playmaking ability, Hill has captured the attention of football enthusiasts worldwide. Beyond his on-field prowess, Hill has become a sought-after figure in the world of sports card collecting and investing.

When it comes to investing, Hill is an interesting case because he doesn’t have too many rookie cards.

He was a fifth-round receiver in the 2016 NFL draft, so not as many sets made his cards (and, in 2016, there weren’t as many sets in general). 

In this article, we’ll explore the top 9 Tyreek Hill rookie cards to consider for long-term investment, excluding short-printed cards to ensure accessibility for collectors.

Please note: To ensure an inclusive and attainable list, I’ve excluded short-printed cards. While a 1-of-1 National rookie card would undoubtedly hold immense value, this list focuses on accessible options that offer significant investment potential.

And if your budget allows, don’t be afraid to buy a refractor/parallel instead of a base of any card on this list.

Shop for Tyreek Hill rookie cards on eBay

Why Invest in Tyreek Hill rookie cards?

Tyreek Hill might be the single most influential non-quarterback in the NFL. There are several compelling reasons why his rookie cards are a sound investment.

On-field brilliance

Hill is not only a superb player but is often regarded as one of the premier wide receivers in the league.

With numerous accolades, including Pro Bowls and All-Pro selections, he has consistently delivered exceptional performances, contributing significantly to the success of his teams.

High demand

Hill’s popularity extends beyond football enthusiasts, boasting a large and dedicated fan base. This widespread appeal contributes to the high demand for his rookie cards.

Market growth

The sports card market has witnessed substantial growth, with the prices of valuable rookie cards soaring. Investing in a player like Hill, known for his explosive playing style, presents an opportune moment in the market.

Excitement factor

Just as Stephen Curry excites with long-range shooting, Hill excites by being able to score on any given play. His deep touchdowns and crazy on-field antics make him a fun watch, and that adds a different kind of value to his cards. 

Record-breaking potential

Hill possesses the potential to break records for receiving yards and touchdowns, adding further intrigue and value to his rookie cards.

Top Tyreek Hill Cards for Investing

Now, let’s take a closer look at the top 9 Tyreek Hill rookie cards to consider for your investment portfolio:

Shop for Tyreek Hill rookie cards on eBay

9. 2016 Certified Mirror Rookies Tyreek Hill #184

A visually striking card, the 2016 Certified Mirror Gold Rookie Tyreek Hill #184 shares the same practice image as the Panini Prizm Rookie #296 but with notable differences.

The mirrored-gold edging accentuates the centered image, complemented by Chiefs and rookie card logos at the bottom corners. Hill’s name is positioned directly below the central image.

With exceptional centering, corners, and eye-catching edges, this card stands out in terms of aesthetics and overall appeal.

8. 2016 Tyreek Hill Rookies & Stars RC #240

The 2016 Tyreek Hill Rookies & Stars card offers a visually appealing addition to Hill’s rookie card lineup. As part of the Rookies & Stars series, known for its vibrant designs, this card features an action shot of Hill in his rookie season, and it’s one of the most affordable cards on this list. 

7. 2016 Panini Select Tyreek Hill #65 Rookie RC

Part of the 2016 Panini Select set, this rookie card captures Tyreek Hill in a classic action shot. With its distinct design and potential for parallel versions, including rare variations, this card is a solid addition for collectors looking to build a comprehensive Tyreek Hill rookie card collection.

6. 2016 Panini Select Tyreek Hill RC  #170

Another entry from the 2016 Panini Select series, this rookie card has the potential for parallel versions, including sought-after variations, this card adds variety to a collector’s Tyreek Hill rookie card portfolio.

Select is a mainstay brand and that alone makes this a good card to chase, and this is the highest tier of scarcity for Tyreek in Select.

5. 2016 Panini Select Tyreek Hill Rookie Autographed Jersey card

A standout in the 2016 Panini Select series, this card combines the excitement of a rookie autograph with a jersey relic, providing collectors with a unique piece of memorabilia.

The Select series is celebrated for its parallel cards, adding an extra layer of rarity and desirability to this autographed rookie card.

4. 2016 Panini Contenders Tyreek Hill Auto RC

This card represents Tyreek Hill in his 2016 Panini Contenders edition, showcasing his autograph. As part of the Contenders series, known for its classic design and coveted autographs, this card appeals to collectors seeking an authentic signature from the dynamic wide receiver.

This is one of the most popular autographs sets every year.

3. 2016 Tyreek Hill Donruss Optic RC #117

In the realm of more traditional rookie cards, the 2016 Tyreek Hill Donruss Optic stands out as a Panini creation. While less chromy than its Prizm counterpart, it is more resistant to scratches, preserving its value.

The card features a thick, bordered design corresponding to the parallel color. The 2016 Donruss set offers two Hill RCs – an autographed version and an unsigned edition.

This description focuses on the former, showcasing a bordered top with a boxed action shot, a stickered auto at the bottom, and various rare parallels for those seeking more valuable investment pieces.

2. 2016 Tyreek Hill National Treasures RC

A standout in the Rookie Patch Autos subset of the popular National Treasures release, this 2016 Tyreek Hill rookie card boasts a landscape design and a premium feel.

Featuring a white and red base card design, Hill’s image is positioned on the right side, with his on-card auto below. The left side accommodates a generous player patch. The National Treasures brand adds value with its recognized name and strong designs, while foil trim color changes in the parallels offer affordability.

Parallels: Silver (/25), Gold (/10), Black (1/1), Blue (1/1), Printing Plates (1/1)

1. 2016 Panini Prizm Tyreek Hill RC

Widely considered an excellent entry-level choice, the 2016 Panini Prizm stands out among Hill’s rookie cards for its varying price points depending on the version.

The card captures Hill in motion, securing a ball under one arm while fully geared up, although his face remains obscured. The distinctive Prizm border adds a unique touch and a prominent RC logo graces the top left corner.

With a broad spectrum of colored parallels, including limited editions like the Gold card with only 10 copies, this card appeals to collectors with diverse budgets.

Parallels: Blue, Flash, Green, Pink, Red, Red/White/Blue Disco, Orange (/299), Light Blue (/199), Blue Wave (/149), Purple Scope (/99), Red Crystals (/75), Green Power (/49), Camo (/25), Gold (/10), Gold Vinyl (/5), Black Finite (1/1)

The bottom line on investing in Tyreek Hill

Tyreek Hill’s combination of on-field brilliance, widespread popularity, and the thriving sports card market make his rookie cards a compelling investment. With a range of autographed and non-autographed options available, collectors and investors have diverse choices to suit their preferences. 

While the market can be unpredictable, diversifying your collection with the top 9 Tyreek Hill rookie cards mentioned above can establish a solid foundation for a successful long-term sports card investment strategy. As Hill continues to make waves in the NFL, the value of these cards is likely to appreciate, making them a smart choice for collectors and investors alike. 

What do you think of Tyreek Hill?  What will his cards be worth in 5 years? Let us know on Twitter @card_lines and be sure to subscribe to our newsletter, which brings investment advice and industry news straight to your inbox twice a week. 

Shop for Tyreek Hill rookie cards on eBay